d0reco verification page - maintained by Lei Wang
To verify new D0GSTAR releases, we compare the new release with former release by making plots for each part of the D0 detector. By doing this, we first generate single particle MC events with mc_runjob. After that, we run Recocert through the output to get root file and overlay two plots from different releases to compare them.
This page shows the comparison of different releases by generationg 2000 50 GeV single pions. The plots below are histograms for d0reco output. The plots for d0gstar output can be found here. The plots for d0sim output (dig) can be found here. In the plots, black histogram is for former release and red dots are for new release.
To test the muon chambers, we also made comparison plots for 50 GeV single muons.
The ones that marked with "new" are the plots after we fixed a bug in our code to have muon hits in d0sim and d0reco plots.
| Releases | Single Particle Sample | VRT | HRT | Comparison Histograms | Comments |
| p10.15.03 | failed.d0gstar2.x did not compile | no | no | no | |
| p11.14.00 | failed.d0gstar2.x did not compile | no | no | no | |
| p13.06.01 | pion_50 | yes | yes | no | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | no | ||
| pion_minimum bias | yes | yes | no | ||
| p13.10.00 | pion_50 | yes | yes | p13.06.01_pion_50_reco_vs_p13.10.00_pion_50_reco.ps | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | p13.06.01_muon_50_reco_vs_p13.10.00_muon_50_reco.ps | ||
| pion_minimum bias | yes | yes | p13.06.01_overlay_reco_vs_p13.10.00_overlay_reco.ps | ||
| p14.03.02 | pion_50 | yes | yes | p13.10.00_pion_50_reco_vs_p14.03.02_pion_50_reco.ps | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | p13.10.00_muon_50_reco_vs_p14.03.02_muon_50_reco.ps | ||
| pion_minimum bias | yes | yes | p13.10.00_overlay_reco_vs_p14.03.02_overlay_reco.ps | ||
| p14.04.00 | pion_50 | yes | yes | p14.03.02_pion_50_reco_vs_p14.04.00_pion_50_reco.ps | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | p14.03.02_muon_50_reco_vs_p14.04.00_muon_50_reco.ps | ||
| pion_minimum bias | yes | yes | p14.03.02_overlay_reco_vs_p14.04.00_overlay_reco.ps | ||
| p14.05.00 | pion_50 | yes | yes | p14.04.00_pion_50_reco_vs_p14.05.00_pion_50_reco.ps | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | p14.04.00_muon_50_reco_vs_p14.05.00_muon_50_reco.ps | ||
| pion_minimum bias. disappeared before compiling | no | no | no | ||
| p14.05.01 | pion_50 | yes | yes | p14.05.00_pion_50_reco_vs_p14.05.01_pion_50_reco.ps | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | p14.03.02_muon_50_reco_vs_p14.05.01_muon_50_reco.ps | ||
| pion_minimum bias | yes | yes | p14.04.00_overlay_reco_vs_p14.05.01_overlay_reco.ps | ||
| p14.05.02 | muon_50 | yes | yes | p14.05.01_muon_50_reco_vs_p14.05.02_muon_50_reco.ps | |
| p14.06.00 | no d0gstar.x file | no | no | no | |
| p14.07.00 | pion_50 | yes | yes | p140502_vs_p140700_pion.ps | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | p140502_vs_p140700_muon.ps | ||
| p14.08.00 | muon_50 | yes | yes | p140502_vs_p140800_1025_muon.ps | |
| pion_50 | yes | yes | p140502_vs_p140800_1027_pion.ps | ||
| p14.09.00 | muon_50 | yes | yes | p140502_vs_p140900_muon_50.ps(new!) | D0gstar geometry in CFT compatible with that in d0sim in p14.09. |
| pion_50 | yes | yes | p140502_vs_p140900_pion_50.ps(new!) | ||
| pion+minbias | yes | yes | p140502_vs_p140900_overlay.ps(new!) | ||
| p15.02.03 | failed at 1st event | no | no | no | |
| p15.05.00 | pion_50 | yes | yes | p14.05.01_pion_50_reco_vs_p15.05.00_pion_50_reco.ps | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | p14.05.01_muon_50_reco_vs_p15.05.00_muon_50_reco.ps | ||
| pion_minimum bias. disappeared before compiling | no | no | no | ||
| p15.06.00 | pion_50 | yes | yes | p15.05.00_pion_50_reco_vs_p15.06.00_pion_50_reco.ps | |
| muon_50 | yes | yes | p15.05.00_muon_50_reco_vs_p15.06.00_muon_50_reco.ps | ||
| pion_minimum bias | yes | yes | p14.05.01_overlay_reco_vs_p15.06.00_overlay_reco.ps | ||
| p15.07.00 | pion_50, failed | no | no | no | |
| muon_50,failed | no | no | no | ||
| pion_minimum bias. failed | no | no | no | ||
| p17.02.00 | muon_50 | yes | yes | p140800_muon_50_vs_p170200_muon_50_reco.ps(new!) | Muon: chisq is different, because in p17, it is chisq/d.o.f. CFT: layer occupancy is wrong in p14 and right in p17. dead channel and hot channel calculation code changed in p17. Cal: ieta,iphi,ilyer changed because of higher noise level in p17.Note: Both p1408 and p1702 have a problem with cft geometry, which is fixed in p14.09 |
| pion_50 | yes | yes | p140800_pion_50_vs_p170200_pion_50_reco.ps(new!) | ||
| pion + Minimum Bias | yes | yes | p1408_vs_p1702_overlay.ps(new!) | ||
| t03.38.00 | failed.d0gstar2.x did not compile | no | no | no | |
| t03.39.00 | failed.d0gstar2.x did not compile | no | no | no | |
| t03.40.00 | failed.d0gstar2.x did not compile | no | no | no |